By Coach Adolfo Salgueiro
As runners, we often enjoy a beer as a post-run reward when we finish a training run with friends. A post-race beer is the perfect excuse for having alcohol at 8 in the morning without having to worry if you’ve become an alcoholic. As ubiquitous as the beer/runner relationship is, there is no definite answer on the conundrum if both can coexist.
There is no binary answer to this dilemma. Scientists and science writers differ on the value and placement of this elixir in the running scene.
Finishing a race is the perfect excuse for downing a beer at 9AM without feeling like an alcoholic.
In the in-favor camp, we find Christie Aschwanden, author of the best-selling book Good to Go: What the Athlete in All of Us Can Learn from the Strange Science of Recovery. During a recent interview in the Run Smarter Podcast she stated:
“Beer and running go hand-in-hand. Together it can be a reasonable recovery drink. No one who does not drink beer should start drinking beer because it will help with their recovery. […] Where I think beer can be a nice thing is that it is a nice sort of ritual for groups that gather after a run and have beer as a social thing, in a way for unwinding. […] Where beer becomes problematic is when you haven’t had food and the alcohol goes to your head. A little bit is fine. The evidence is not there to say that one beer or a beer-and-a-half is going to wreck your recovery. There is evidence that knocking 6 or 7 beers in a row is not good for you. Hangovers are not good for recovery.”
They key to Ms. Aschwanden point is that beer per se has no magical powers as a recovery drink. The fact we do it as a social ritual after we put the mile in, is what makes it a positive stimulus. “The social aspect of relaxing with your friends is helpful”, she stated. The key, as usual, is moderation.
But not everyone is in favor of a post-race cold brew. According an article by Holy Martin, a San Francisco-based running coach and personal trainer, in the Run to The Finish blog: “After a training session, our body utilizes protein to rebuild itself, and to adapt to what we’re demanding of it while training. Alcohol can impede that process and make it much harder for our muscles to rebuild. Similarly, alcohol freezes muscle growth if you’re consuming it on a regular basis. So, if you’re working hard to build speed or strength, or to make any real changes in the gym, be mindful of your alcohol consumption.”
The social aspect of the post-run beer alone, has its positive recovery effects
When you think of it from the scientific point of view, this makes sense. But she also states at the end “be mindful”, not necessarily “refrain”. So it comes, once more, to moderation.
In an article published by Runner’s World in August of this year (2020), author Heather Mayer Irvine said that:” Experts agree that beer, which is considered a diuretic—thus dehydrating—isn’t the best recovery drink and should be paired with water when consumed after a workout. Still, a 2015 study published in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition found that when runners drank a moderate alcoholic beer (roughly 4.5 percent ABV) along with water after a workout, their rehydration was no worse than those who drank only water.”
Since we are discussing alcohol consumption, it is imperative that you understand that drinking right before or while running is a definitely no-no. You don’t want your liver using the glucose needed to propel you forward, processing the alcohol you are consuming. This is a recipe for a crash. If you can’t wait until the training or race is over, maybe it is time to make an appointment with an addiction specialist.
My Personal Conclusion
I am not a scientist or a doctor, so I speak from the experience of a runner who has indulged in the post-run cold one with his buddies for a few years. Sure, we can enjoy a post-run libation without ruining what we just gained, but at the same time, beer doesn’t have any esoteric powers in our recovery. The social aspect of it is what brings us joy while we are in a runners’-high state. It is this feeling what will bring us back to do more running so we can experience the ritual again. Of course, in moderation, and only after drinking enough water first, so we don’t rehydrate with alcohol.